Struggling to recruit? Small law firms can win talent by showing why people should join. Practical steps on pay, development and your story.
If recruitment is proving difficult, you’re not alone. The Law Society’s Small Firm Manifesto: Supporting small law firms and sole practitioners in England and Wales, published in October 2026, reports that 85% of research respondents identified recruitment and retention as their biggest challenge.
The manifesto calls for stronger apprenticeship support, clearer entry routes and regional collaboration on legal skills. Those are welcome proposals. Alongside them, I’d ask a question closer to home: what can your firm do now to become somewhere people want to join and stay?
My view is that small firms have more to offer than they sometimes recognise. You may not match a larger firm’s pay and benefits, but close client relationships, varied work and a genuine say in the business matter too. Be clear about what working at your firm is like, then help prospective colleagues see how they could build a future with you.
Look at your website through the eyes of someone thinking about joining you. Can they get a feel for the work, the people and the opportunities? An up-to-date website, a thoughtful LinkedIn presence and a well-presented Review Solicitors profile can help people get to know your practice.
Introduce the team, show your involvement in the community and share genuine examples of flexible working in practice. You don’t need to make your firm look bigger than it is. Help people see what makes it a good place to work.
An employer value proposition comes down to a straightforward question: why would someone choose to work at your firm? You don’t need complicated language, just a clear answer.
I’d start with what the job would look like: the work, the balance between variety and specialism, and the client contact and autonomy someone can expect. Be equally clear about supervision, billing expectations, flexible hours and hybrid working. If there’s a route to promotion, explain the steps involved. That tells someone far more than “excellent career prospects”.
If relationships are a strength, explain what that means for someone joining you. Create a short “Why work here?” website section and carry the message into adverts and interviews. Keep it honest: your existing team should recognise the firm you’re describing.
Not every high street practice can match larger regional or City firms on salary. I recognise that, but wider benefits shouldn’t sidestep an honest conversation about pay. Be clear about what you can offer alongside the culture and opportunities you’ve described.
Check what comparable local and regional employers are paying and get as close as you realistically can. Then look at the whole package: which benefits can you provide, and what would someone joining you value? Explain when salaries are reviewed and how bonuses work, including any discretion. The aim is a clear, credible offer – not promises you may struggle to keep.
Be specific about personal development. Rather than simply promising support, explain what someone could work towards—a specialist accreditation, stronger advocacy skills or leadership training – and how regular mentoring with an experienced colleague could help. Give prospective recruits something tangible to consider.
I’d also look beyond legal training. Business development, managing client relationships and helping to run the practice offer valuable experience for lawyers interested in the business as well as the law. Whatever you offer, put a practical plan behind it, with time, resources and someone responsible for making it happen.
Recruitment should give people a feel for working with you. Write a straightforward advert explaining the role and next steps, and respond promptly. Let candidates meet the supervising partner and a potential colleague, with time for questions. You’re both assessing the fit, so make it an open conversation.
Keep an open mind about how the role could work. Part-time roles, consultancy arrangements, flexible fee-sharing models or portfolio careers may suit your practice, provided they fit the work and supervision available. Consider flexibility from the outset – not only when a conventional advert hasn’t attracted the right people.
Recruitment consultants can help, but I’d encourage you to speak directly to prospective colleagues as well. A focused LinkedIn campaign, supported by a clear website message, lets you explain what your firm offers in your own words.
Keep the message consistent: the work you do, how you work together and how someone could develop. You’re not simply announcing a vacancy; you’re giving someone a reason to start a conversation.
That conversation is an opportunity to show why your firm could be the right choice. My view is that small firms have every reason to be positive about recruitment: you don’t have to be the biggest firm to be the right firm for someone. Varied work, close client relationships, flexibility and the chance to make a visible contribution give people good reasons to choose you – provided those strengths are reflected in their experience after joining.
Recruitment will still take effort and pay matters. But being small needn’t mean being overlooked. Start with what you can genuinely offer, help people see how they could build a future with you, and follow through on your promises. You’re not asking someone to settle for a smaller firm. You’re giving them a reason to choose yours.
If you would like to discuss any of the themes raised in this blog, please contact me on 07916669095 or ih@hopkinslegalconsulting.co.uk. I’d be delighted to hear from you.